icon

The Largest Choice of Beauty Salon Equipment in the UK. Learn more

15 Must Try Best Eyeliner For Your Eye Color in 2023

Best Eyeliner For Your Eye Color

The makeup and cosmetics are used to enhance the appearance of facial features. Although it does improve, these must be applied accordingly to the natural features of the face. These natural features may be face shape, eye shape, skin tone, and eye colour. For instance, applying eyeliner must be aligned with the natural colour of the eyes. It is due to the fact that using random colours may contradict the eye colour and may result in an underwhelming look. 

Given that scenario, the 15 must-try best eyeliners for every eye colour are meticulously identified and chosen to provide the best eyeliner with the potential to enhance the eyes. The qualifications of these eyeliners are based on formulation, build quality, production, and pricing. These things cover all the consumer's necessities and demands for an eyeliner that matches the eye colour. For example, the MAC Liner in Late Night is best for Light Brown Eyes. It is because of its warm tone that compliments the light brown eyes that also projects the same warmness. The intense green pigment of the eyeliner also makes the light brown colour stand out. 

Listed below are the top 3 best eyeliners for the eye colour in 2023.

  • Best for Dark Brow: KVD Vegan Beauty Super Pomade Eyeliner is the best for dark brows as it fills the gap between them. The eyeliner is very versatile, which makes it a great alternative for eye cosmetics. 
  • Best for Light Brown Eyes: MAC Liner in Late Night is the best for brown eyes due to its dark and cool-toned shade. The contradictory tones of brown and dark green make it a great combination as it enhances each other’s colour. 
  • Best for Hazel Eyes: NYX Retractable Eyeliner is the best for hazel eyes because it has 13 varying shades that are all suitable for hazel eyes. The colour hazel is a combination of two tones, which makes it versatile among any colour.

  • 1. KVD Vegan Beauty Super Pomade Eyeliner (Best for Dark Brow)

    KVD Vegan Beauty Super Pomade Eyeliner is a 3-in-1 waterproof eyeliner in a tube that can last for almost 17 hours of wearing without reapplying the product. The KVD Vegan Beauty Super Pomade is also designed to use as an eyeshadow and fill the spaces in the eyebrows. It has a creamy texture and the pigment of the product is not accessible to be removed without using makeup remover. The product is also available in 16 shades that are perfect for every skin eye colour. It can be purchased for an average price of £18.91 GBP. KVD Vegan Beauty Super Pomade Eyeliner is rated by its valued customers as 4.7 out of 5 stars due to its longevity that can last for almost 17 hours of wearing the product.

    KVD Vegan Beauty Super Pomade Eyeliner Advantages

    KVD Vegan Beauty Super Pomade Eyeliner Disadvantages

    Easy-to-use

    Not a Transfer-proof

    Long-lasting

    Expensive


    2. MAC Liner in Late Night (Best for Light Brown Eyes)

    The MAC Liner in Late Night is known for being the best when it comes to longevity, waterproof and cruelty-free. The product can last 16 up to 24 hours of use without any smudging and fading of pigment of the eyeliner. It can be applied using a brush to draw a perfect design according to the preference of the customer, and the product is easy to use and lasts long. It is perfect for light brown eyes, as its pigment is warm-toned and deep green. Its price is around £17.25 GBP on the market. The MAC Liner in Late Night has received a rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars from its valued customers as it is long-lasting, waterproof, and compliments the light brown eyes very well. 

    MAC Liner in Late Night

    Advantages

    MAC Liner in Late Night

    Disadvantages

    Lasts All Day

    Prone to Smudge on Oily Skin

    Withstand Water

    May not be Suitable with Other Eye Colours


    3. NYX Retractable Eyeliner (Best for Hazel Eyes)

    The NYX Retractable Eyeliner is a highly-pigmented and creamy eyeliner that gives the eyes a good colour payoff. It is also formulated to last long on the lash and water lines due to its ultra-staying technology. The product is easy to use, as it has a smooth texture that can be easily glided for an accurate application. Not only that but the NYX Retractable Eyeliner is infused with moisturising and hydrating ingredients that nourish the eyes well. It comes in 13 different shades that suit various eye colours, especially brown, black, green, and hazel. The eyeliner can be purchased for an average price of £5.34 GBP. Its rating given by its valued customers is 4.2 out of 5 stars, mainly because of its smooth and easy-to-apply formulation. 

    NYX Retractable Eyeliner

    Advantages

    NYX Retractable Eyeliner

    Disadvantages

    Easy to Remove

    Prone to Smudge

    Glides on Smoothly

    May Fade Throughout the Day


    4. Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner in Midnight Blue

    The Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner in Midnight Blue is designed to be used as eyeliner and eyeshadow, while using the hands without smudging and infused with vibrant colour. The product is also easy-to-use, that's why many people love the product, especially beginners. The product will last for almost  4 to 8 hours of use. It also has a matte and shimmer finish. The Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner in Midnight Blue can be purchased in a price range of £18.07 GBP to  £19.71 GBP. The product is rated by its valued customers as 4.4 out of 5 stars because the product is easy-to-use.

    Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner in Midnight Blue

    Advantages

    Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner in Midnight Blue

    Disadvantages

    Easy-to-use

    Broke off easily

    Waterproof

    Poor twist-up ability


    5. MAC Powerpoint Eye Pencil in Bordeauxline

    The Mac Powerpoint Eye Pencil in Bordeauxline is a limited edition product eyeliner with cool-toned purple colour which is good for hazel eye colour. It has medium coverage that lasts for almost 10 hours wearing the eyeliner. The product is also available in a matte finish and is best applied for short strokes. The texture is a little waxy but free from any smudges. The MAC Powerpoint Eye Pencil in Bordeauxline can be purchased in a price range of £12.32 GBP to £13.14 GBP. It is rated 4.2 out of 5 stars due to its good formulation of the product.

    MAC Powerpoint Eye Pencil in Bordeauxline Advantages

    MAC Powerpoint Eye Pencil in Bordeauxline

    Disadvantages

    Long-lasting

    It did not glide smoothly

    Easy-to-used

    Can cause allergy


    6. Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Liquid Liner in black

    The Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Liquid Liner in Black is a waterproof eyeliner with an ultra-fine tip to achieve the most defined and precise line that can last for almost 13 hours of wearing the liquid eyeliner. The product is also ophthalmologist-tested and dermatologist-tested, which is safe for those who have sensitive skin on the eyelid part. The product can be purchased in a price range of £12.32 GBP to £13.14 GBP. Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Liquid Liner in Black is rated by its valued customers as 4.5 out of 5 stars due to its ultra-fine feature for an easy application to achieve a cat eye look.

    Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Liquid Liner in black

    Advantages

    Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Liquid Liner in black

    Disadvantages

    Smudge-free

    The Coverage is Too Light

    Ophthalmologist-tested and

    Dermatologist-tested

    Dried out in Short Time


    7. NYX Cosmetics Slide on Pencil in Brown Perfection

    NYX Cosmetics Slide on Pencil in Brown Perfection is a smooth, waterproof, and cruelty-free pencil eyeliner that delivers high pigmented colours that last all over the day without reapplying the product. The NYX Cosmetics Slide on Pencil in Brown Perfection is available in 18 intense shades that are best for everyone, particularly for those people starting to learn how to create any look such as cat eye, drop eye, and thin line. The Brown Perfection is suitable for eyes with black, brown, blue, hazel, and green eyes. It can be purchased for an average price of  £7.79 GBP and, is rated by its valued customers as 4.5 out of 5 stars because the product is easy to use and there are a lot of shades to choose from.

    NYX  Cosmetics Slide on Pencil in Brown Perfection 

    Advantages

    NYX  Cosmetics Slide on Pencil in Brown Perfection 

    Disadvantages

    Long-lasting

    Difficult to Sharpen

                                Pigmented

    Not Smudge-free


    8. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Smog

    The Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Smog is an award-winning waterproof pencil eyeliner that has a creamy, soft texture that glides smoothly. It is packed with vitamin E and jojoba oil that is known to provide moisture and hydration to avoid dryness and irritation. The waterproofing technology in the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Smog can withstand intense water splashes and the flow of tears and sweat. It is also easy to use as its formulation is smooth; thus, a skipped application brought by hard and rough texture can be avoided. The Smog shade is most suitable for those with black and brown eyes, as it gives a smokey finish. The product is currently available on the market in a price range of £18.07 GBP. It is rated 4.4 out of 5 stars by its valued customers because of its smooth texture and hydrating effects. 

    Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Smog

    Advantages

    Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Smog

    Disadvantages

    Sensitive-friendly

    Poor Build Quality

    Highly Pigmented

    Prone to Smudge


    9. Sephora Collection12hr Colorful Contour Eyeliner in Flirting Game

    The Sephora Collection 12hr Colourful Contour Eyeliner in Flirting Game is a great eyeliner when opting to have an accurate glide on the lash and water lines. The skipping and inaccurate application will totally be avoided when using the product. It can also be used for a long period of time due to its 12-hour hold; thus, the consumer will not have to worry about fading. The brownish shade of the flirting game variant is perfect for darker eye colours such as black, blue and deep brown. The product is now available for around £14.92 GBP. It has received a rating of 4.1 out of 5 stars due to its smooth gel formulation that can be glided easily and quickly. 

    Sephora Collection 12hr Colourful Contour Eyeliner in Flirting Game

    Advantages

    Sephora Collection 12hr Colourful Contour Eyeliner in Flirting Game

    Disadvantages

    Smooth Gel

    May Cause Eye Irritation

    Highly Pigmented

    Poor Build Quality


    10. Fenty Beauty Flyliner Liquid Eyeliner

    The Fenty Beauty Flyliner Liquid Eyeliner provides a good colour payoff as it consists of liquid formula. The eyeliner scales its boldness and intensity as the pressure of the application is increasing. It is a long-lasting liquid eyeliner that can be worn for several hours upon application. The light brown shade of the product is very suitable for deep coloured eyes, such as black, dark brown, amber, dark green, etc. It is available and can be purchased in both physical and online stores for an average price of £22.21 GBP. The Fenty Beauty Flyliner Liquid Eyeliner has received 3.8 out of 5 stars, mainly because it is easy to control for accurate application, smooth glide, and can be dried quickly to avoid smudges. 

    Fenty Beauty Flyliner Liquid Eyeliner

    Advantages

    Fenty Beauty Flyliner Liquid Eyeliner

    Disadvantages

    Smooth Application

    Pricey

    Accurate Glide

    Not Transfer-proof


    11. Black Opal COLORSPLURGE Precision Eye Definer

    The Black Opal COLORSPLURGE Precision Eye Definer has an automatic sharpener, so there’s no need to worry about sharpening the pencil eyeliner. The product will help to define the eyes with the soft and creamy texture of the Black Opal COLORSPLURGE Precision Eye Definer upon application. The longevity of the product is also good, it lasts for almost 15 hours of wearing the product with no smudging and fading of colour. The product can be purchased at an average price of  £6.98 GBP and, is rated by its valued customers as 5 out of 5 stars because of the automatic sharpener of the product.

    Black Opal COLORSPLURGE Precision Eye Definer

    Advantages

    Black Opal COLORSPLURGE Precision Eye Definer

    Disadvantages

    No Smear

    Not Transfer-free

    With Automatic Sharpener

    Does not Have a Strong Waterproofing Feature


    How to choose the best eyeliner for your eye colour?

    The best eyeliners for blue eyes are in the shades of bronze to orange. These shades are complimentary with the colour blue. With these warm-toned colours, blue eyes will appear more defined because of the contradictory tones. Hazel eye colour, on the other hand, consists of a green and brown combination; thus it suits almost every shade available. If the consumer opts to showcase the green part of the eyes, it is better to apply eyeliner in the shades of purple or lavender, as it promotes a more greeny effect on the eyes. Meanwhile, the brownish part will be good with warmer tones as well, such as golden to bronze shades. Furthermore, brown eyes can be good with almost everything as it is very common eye colour. The shades of brown and other warm-toned eyeliners are suitable if brown eyes’ goal is to look more natural. However, if choosing a more enhanced look, then contradictory and complementary colours are more suitable like purple and green shades. With that being said, the question, “how to choose the right eyeliner for your eye colour?” has now been solved. 

    What are the best colour of eyeliners for hazel eyes?

    There are several brands that produce amazing eyeliners every year which also have different beautiful shades. These may be tempting to use, but unfortunately, some of them may not be suitable for the consumer's eye colour, especially the hazel ones. Hazel eyes are one of the most versatile eye colours, but just like others, there are shades that may not be suitable for them. Listed below are the best eyeliner colours for hazel eyes that will totally eliminate the question, “what colour eyeliner for hazel eyes?”.

  • NYX Retractable Eyeliner: The NYX Retractable Eyeliner is best suited for hazel eyes due to its varying shades. The 13 different shades of the NYX Retractable Eyeliner can enhance the beautiful dual-toned colour of the hazel eyes. The eyeliner can be purchased for an average price of £5.34 GBP. 
  • MAC Powerpoint Eye Pencil in Bordeauxline: With its cool-toned purple, the hazel eyes can have a more popping appearance. The purple shade will brighten the greener part of the eyes, which makes it more dominant. The MAC Powerpoint Eye Pencil in Bordeauxline can be purchased in a price range of £12.32 GBP to £13.14 GBP.
  • NYX Cosmetics Slide on Pencil in Brown Perfection: The NYX Cosmetics Slide on Pencil in Brown Perfection, on the other hand, offers the brownish part of the hazel eyes brightening. It blends well with brown, which gives it a bright and natural appearance. It can be purchased for an average price of  £7.79 GBP.

  • What are the best eyeliners for blue eyes?

    Blue eyes are one of the most beautiful eye colours in the world. Its bright and crystal clear blue looks make it eye-catching. Thus, when using eyeliner, the stunning features of the blue eyes must be kept or even enhanced. Listed below are the best eyeliners for blue eyes.

  • Sephora Collection12hr Colorful Contour Eyeliner in Flirting Game: The Sephora Collection 12hr Colourful Contour Eyeliner in Flirting Game’s brown shades is perfect for blue eyes. It can make the eyes appear brighter as these two colours are complementary to each other. The product is now available for around £14.92 GBP.
  • Fenty Beauty Flyliner Liquid Eyeliner: The warm-toned brown shade of the Fenty Beauty Flyliner Liquid Eyeliner is another blue-popping shade. Due to its warm appearance, the blue eyes will appear cooler and dominant. It is available and can be purchased in both physical and online stores for an average price of £22.21 GBP.
  • NYX Cosmetics Slide on Pencil in Brown Perfection: The NYX Cosmetics Slide on Pencil in Brown Perfection is another warm-toned brown shade that does not just compliment the blue eyes, but also makes it more realistic and bright. It can be purchased for an average price of  £7.79 GBP.

  • Can I wear bright eyeliner even if it doesn't match the colour of my eyes?

    Yes, bright eyeliner can still be worn even if it does not match the colour of the eyes. However, it is important to remember that unmatched cosmetics may ruin the entire look. Wearing a bright eyeliner, especially on brighter eye colours, may make it look underwhelming. Thus, opting for an eyeliner colour that matches the eyes is a must.